The Poppy War

The Poppy War

Book - 2018
Average Rating:
Rate this:
14
5
1
 …
A war orphan rises from her humble beginnings to become a powerful military commander, and perhaps her country's only hope for survival.
Publisher: New York, N.Y. : Harper Voyager, an imprint of HarperCollinsPublishers, [2018]
Edition: First edition
ISBN: 9780062662569
0062662562
Branch Call Number: SCI-FIC KUANG 2018
Characteristics: 530 pages : map ; 24 cm

Opinion

From Library Staff

Peasant Rin gains admission to the prestigious military school Sinegar, where she is treated as an outcast but discovers an aptitude for the nearly-mythical art of shamanism. With a war on the horizon, Rin hones her powers.

Fantasy - short list


From the critics


Community Activity

Comment

Add a Comment
j
Jacqua4030
Aug 30, 2019

Réservé à la Bibliothèque de Gatineau

e
EliK1
Aug 23, 2019

I gave in to the hype and checked this book out. I kept turning the pages, hoping that it would just get better. But it never really did. The main character acts like a spoiled brat, who thinks she knows better than anyone else. So annoying. But if you like reading about an empowered female teenager, then go for it. I hate kid characters who take over the adult world. How probable is it really that a group of teenagers kills plenty of experienced soldiers?

What I did enjoy was the mythical portion of the book, in which we learned about different gods. But that could have been described in a chapter.

j
JLMason
Apr 26, 2019

This is a richly imagined fantasy that draws upon a (roughly) 19th century Asia as its backdrop and parallels the wars between China and Japan, renamed Nikara and Mugen respectively. It’s a coming-of-age tale about a courageous orphan who must learn how to channel the power of the spirit world and accept the consequences. The story is divided into three parts, each of such different tenor as to be almost different books, all hard to put down. Part 1 is a delightful read about the innocence of youth preparing for war. Part 2 begins a descent into the darkness of war. Part 3 is a horrific tale of atrocities, genocide, and rage, likely based on the Sacking of Nanking. War is dehumanizing and there is no honour. The shocking ending sets the stage for a sequel.

f
fionajay
Mar 19, 2019

Nominated for Nebula Awards 2019

JCLBetM Nov 20, 2018

I wanted to like this so much more. Clever female warrior protagonist? Sign me up! The world and plot were interesting (though sometimes slow), but somehow every time I thought I was supposed to feel something my heart was unmoved--and my heart is always ready to be moved. Yet I was left only mentally rooting for the story. It's still worth reading just for a new female-led flavor of this type of story. I'm hoping that somehow the author imbues her sequel(s) with whatever is necessary to lift the characters off the page into the literary world of real-(though-of course--not-real) that'll make me care about everything happening to them.

JessicaGma Aug 27, 2018

The world-building is complex and there are some great plot twists in this story. Rin was making some bad decisions in her quest to fulfill her destiny, and I hope this continues on, as I need some more closure as to what Rin does next. If not, it's a good study of whether revenge is a good thing to pursue. or if it causes more issues and should be left to the universe.

p
Pressroom
Aug 03, 2018

I was amazed this book was written by a first-time author. It's a fast-paced action fantasy that tries to deal with some big themes. A good read and pretty hard to put down.

l
Lunytoucan
Jul 17, 2018

I read 342 pages of this book before I decided to go spend my time on something worthwhile. I appreciate that there is a lot of good world building involved in this book and I accept that it is dark and violent. The problem is the characters never got better and I finally gave up on them. There is no one to cheer for in this book, everybody is shallow, angry and petty. To be have revenge, there has to be an injury or wrong suffered. RIn really doesn't have that, she has anger issues. She hates her life no matter where she is in it.

alburke47 Jul 15, 2018

No doubt if you are into fantasy, you have heard of this book doing the rounds. It's getting a lot of praise, and rightly so - for the most part.

<i>The Poppy War</i> tells the story of Rin, a war orphan brought up by drug dealers in a fantasy world called Nikara, akin to maybe late Middle Ages China. Rin is driven, willing to do what it takes to rise above her station, and wants to enter the prestigious Sinegard academy, where future military officers are trained. However, the Mugeni (Japanese) army is invading (again), and her training is cut short and she must learn to control her burgeoning powers while staying alive. So far, so great.

However, here's the niggles (as opposed to the Wiggles):

1. School: Pre-Sinegard is great, as she must fight just to do the entrance exam for the Academy. The actual school bit is not so great. It's strikes as mostly formulaic (with some nice surprises), and the fight scene at the end of her first year is straight out of Karate Kid, although Mr Myagi would not approve of the ending. Her relationship with her seemingly insane master Jiang is very nicely done.

2. Random technological suggestions: For example, there is mention of a scene where the Mugeni round up and shoot some Nikaran prisoners, yet not a gun is to be seen (except for some cannons). The Mugeni also have hypodermic needles, which may have actually been a thing at the time.

3. Zombie characters: "Why do characters suddenly appear, every time you are near?" Okay, they're not zombies, but characters have a habit of popping back into the narrative at convenient times. This is partially because it's told in first person (I'm a big fan). Sometimes it's nicely done, other times it's a bit irksome.

4. It seems like there are gaps in the story: There are gaps in the story, but sometimes (correct me if I'm wrong) it feels like we are jumping forward in time rapidly with little explanation for it. Part of this is the first-person narrative, but when you leave gaps in the story, we fill it in ourselves - which is a terrible idea as we're all used to reading fantasy tropes (aaaggghhh!!!). The tale is relatively long (527 pages in hardback), but it's pacy and enjoyable, and I could easily have handled another 100 pages of additional material. This, of course, could be down to the publishers, maybe we'll get an author's cut down the road.

Enough with moaning though. It's a great read. Rin is terrific, as are her two mentors, Jiang and Altan. It's kind of a love story, but more friendship than knocking boots. I could not in good conscience given it less than five stars.

b
black_beaver_52
Jul 12, 2018

Kinda predictable plot, with events borrowed directly from Chinese history in last 100 years or so, but it’s really well written, funny and brutally violent. I couldn’t put the book down and finished in 2 days.

View All Comments

Notices

Add Notices
e
edithmc
Sep 12, 2018

Sexual Content: Rape

e
edithmc
Sep 12, 2018

Violence: Descriptive Violence Selfharm

s
shayshortt
May 16, 2018

Sexual Content: References to off-page sexual assault

s
shayshortt
May 16, 2018

Violence: War and genocide

s
shayshortt
May 16, 2018

Coarse Language: Liberal use of the word "fuck"

Age

Add Age Suitability
CoreneBee May 14, 2018

CoreneBee thinks this title is suitable for 17 years and over

Summary

Add a Summary
s
shayshortt
May 16, 2018

Rin is a war orphan, being raised by the Fang family only because the government has mandated that families adopt such children, and because they find it convenient to use her to help them in their drug smuggling business. Living in the deep rural south of the Nikara Empire, Rin dreams of passing the Keju exam, and traveling north to study at one of the empire’s elite schools. But when her hard work pays off and she tests into Sinegard, the top military academy in the country, Rin discovers that her trials are only beginning. Sinegard’s military and political elite have little time or sympathy for a dark-skinned peasant girl from the south. Desperate to prove herself, Rin unlocks a supposedly mythical power that enables her to summon the strength of the gods. Even as she is further alienated from her teachers and classmates, she becomes the protégé of an eccentric master who has taken no other apprentices from her class. But Master Jiang wants Rin to learn to control and suppress her abilities, while Rin dreams of wielding them in battle for the glory of the Empire. And with the Empire constantly on the brink of the next war with the Mugen Federation, it becomes increasingly difficult to heed her Master’s advice and resist the call of the Phoenix, god of fire and vengeance.

Quotes

Add a Quote
s
shayshortt
May 16, 2018

The Keju is a ruse to keep uneducated peasants right where they’ve always been. You slip past the Keju, they’ll find a way to expel you anyway. The Keju keeps the lower classes sedated. It keeps us dreaming. It’s not a ladder for mobility; it’s a way to keep people like me exactly where they were born. The Keju is a drug.

Explore Further

Browse by Call Number

Recommendations

Subject Headings

  Loading...

Find it at SPL

  Loading...
[]
[]
To Top